Skip to content
Crown Exchange

The Concealed Ecological Impact of Highly-Processed Products: Why the Industry Should Pay

If you inspect a package of M&Ms, one of the best-selling candies in the US, you'll see recognizable components like sugar, skimmed milk powder, and chocolate fat. However, many more items are unfamiliar: gum arabic, dextrin, carnauba wax, soya lecithin, and curcumin.

You'll find 34 ingredients in M&Ms, and no fewer than thirty countries participating in supplying them. Every one has its distinct production network that converts base substances into usable parts – cocoa into cocoa liquor, cane into sugar, petroleum into blue food dye.

These components then journey globally to a main manufacturing plant where they are combined and transformed into small blue, red, yellow and green chocolate gems.

It's becoming more widely recognized that food systems are a major driver of the environmental emergency. Researchers can examine land clearing for farming or methane emissions from livestock. Yet the ecological footprint of ultra-processed foods – such as these candies – is less clear and is just beginning to come into focus. One reason they have been so difficult to assess is the inherent complexity of ultra-processed foods: these factory-produced items include a vast array of ingredients and procedures to put them together, making it nearly impossible to monitor.

However, this doesn't imply it's unimportant. As UPFs take over US grocery store shelves and eating habits – they now account for seventy percent of food sold in supermarkets, and more than half of calories consumed – specialists say that assessing their environmental toll is essential to create a greener food system.

The Information We Already Understand

Although researchers are only starting to investigate the environmental impact of ultra-processed foods, existing knowledge about them is worrisome.

"The greater the processing products become, the more harmful they are to human health and the planet," said a senior researcher. The primary cause, he explains, is that the ingredients are so energy intensive. Once assembled, the toll expands significantly.

Take the popular candy. The first step in producing the sweets is cultivating for cocoa, sweetener, dairy and palm oil.

There is extensive evidence that farming for ingredients like cocoa drives consistently rising rates of forest clearance worldwide. For over a century, agricultural expansion has driven almost 90% of global deforestation, which has been responsible for thirty percent of global greenhouse gas emissions. Large corporations have been called out in the past for agricultural methods in their production network, and have since created environmental initiatives, but these fail to address that large-scale agricultural practices are, fundamentally, unsustainable.

Additionally, sugar, dried dairy and palm fat – also major greenhouse gas emitters.

On top of that are the industrially made components like food dyes – perhaps the signature of ultra-processing – which M&Ms contain thirteen varieties of. The blue candies are dyed with artificial blue dyes; these dyes are primarily produced in food dye manufacturing hotspots Asia, through synthetic processes of petroleum derivatives with chemical compounds, accelerated by the metals copper or chromium.

Producing soy lecithin, an ingredient made from soybean oil that's used to change the consistency of candy, requires steps like degumming in a heated vessel, extracting fat molecules, bleaching using hydrogen peroxide and dehydrating under vacuum pressure. And, dextrose, begins as maize that gets steeped in acid before being milled, separated and dehydrated. From there, it's decomposed into simpler compounds using biological catalysts and chemicals, and then recrystallized.

While highly manufactured candies are some of the worst offenders, different types of ultra-processed foods are burdensome on the planet as well. Consider another popular snack, which has thirty-nine components. Maize is the main ingredient, and for every hectare grown, 1,000kg of CO2 is emitted to the atmosphere. Similar to other corporations, producers have developed their own sustainability promises, but several such promises are underpinned by methods that are considered superficial eco-claims.

As a result, researchers have started to calculate the environmental toll of UPFs.

One analysis calculated that popular candies generate at least 13.2kg of carbon equivalents per kilogram produced. With annual production of more than six hundred million kilograms in the US, this would mean that the candies emit at least 3.8 million tons of CO2 – accounting for 0.1% of annual emissions in the country. But, this is just a calculation based on accessible information; the actual impact is likely significantly greater, according to specialists.

There's a "unknown element" when it comes to carbon accounting in the manufactured food sector, says Patrick Callery who studies how companies engage with the environmental challenge. "There exists so much ambiguity as supply chains get complicated."

The Gaps We Don't Know

Calculating precisely of the environmental toll of ultra-processed foods is nearly impossible, since, definitionally, UPFs consist of many ingredients and a significant number of opaque processes. Ingredients aren't just combined like one would do to make a stew at home. Rather, these elements are altered synthetically, certain portions stripped away, and flavors, dyes or consistencies incorporated – and it's unclear what the cost of these methods are because numerous providers and parts are included.

Another reason is that every ultra-processed food are the products of manufacturing corporations that have minimal motivation to disclose their environmental footprint and might not fully understand it to start with.

For instance, major brands do not farm key ingredients themselves, but instead rely on hundreds of farms that don't always have precise emissions tracking in place. This means that emissions from big food corporations may be underreported. Analysts said that corporations "lack real measurements, so they use estimated values, which are approximations."

Researchers say that corporations provide reports on simple things like shipping, which are simpler to measure, and often omit or convolute the agricultural emissions of their items. After all, reporting high emissions goes against the objectives of large food corporations, so the complex calculations needed to determine the carbon footprint of industrial farming and multi-step industrial chemical processes used to make processed food components remain understudied.

"The primary goal of ultra-processed foods is profit," said the researcher, pointing out that they're created to be appealing, convenient and pleasurable to eat.

"The majority of individuals in the food industry's production network don't care about climate change from an ethical perspective, but they are interested in money," said another expert. He explains that to shift those incentives, the cost of products and components would need to incorporate their effect on our shared climate. But that would require government regulations and financial penalties based on the actual ecological impact of UPFs.

The Reasons It Matters

At just under $2, the cost of M&Ms at the supermarket barely represents their real impact on the planet. But to tackle these issues with manufactured products, not only a few tweaks to the ingredient list are needed.

"Reducing the salt, or sugar of just a single item is just superficial eco-marketing," stated the expert. "We need to change the whole picture." To do that, he suggested consuming more regionally produced, whole foods, which often take far fewer resources and transit to create, and therefore have a significantly reduced carbon footprint.

Specialty goods that can't be sourced locally, like chocolate, should {make up|constitute

TO
About the author

Tom Obrien

A seasoned gaming analyst and content strategist specializing in UK betting markets and casino reviews.

Crown Exchange

Type to search articles.